THE MARROW JOURNAL · Steak cuts
Tri-Tip vs Picanha: How These Two Sirloin Roasts Differ
Tri-tip and picanha are both boneless sirloin roasts with triangular profiles, but they are not the same muscle. Tri-tip comes from the bottom sirloin; picanha, also sold as coulotte or top sirloin cap, covers the top sirloin. Their grain, fat arrangement and portioning call for different buying and cooking decisions.
Tri-tip and picanha at a glance
The comparison uses USDA Institutional Meat Purchase Specifications and Beef Checkoff cut references. Retail labels vary, so the muscle location and trim specification are more reliable than the nickname alone.
| Question | Tri-tip | Picanha / coulotte |
|---|---|---|
| Where it comes from | Bottom sirloin butt | Top sirloin cap |
| Common wholesale identifier | IMPS 185C; 185D is the defatted version | IMPS 184D |
| Other names | Triangle roast, Santa Maria roast, Newport roast | Coulotte, sirloin cap, top sirloin cap |
| Typical purchase | Whole triangular roast or portion-cut steaks | Whole cap roast, often purchased with a specified exterior-fat layer |
| Useful methods | Indirect grilling, roasting, smoking, broiling or sous vide | Indirect grilling, roasting, smoking or portioning for skewers |
| Slicing issue | The grain can change direction across the roast | Identify the grain before cutting the cap into portions |
Sources: Beef Checkoff — Tri-Tip Roast cut guide (industry source) · Beef Checkoff — Tri-Tip Steak cut guide and 1185C identifier (industry source) · Beef Checkoff — Coulotte/Picanha Roast cut guide and 184D identifier (industry source) · USDA Agricultural Marketing Service — Institutional Meat Purchase Specifications
They come from opposite sides of the sirloin
Tri-tip is separated from the bottom sirloin butt. USDA’s Series 100 beef specification identifies boneless tri-tip as IMPS 185C and a defatted boneless version as 185D. The Beef Checkoff describes the whole roast as triangular, boneless and suited to roasting or grilling.
Picanha is the market name commonly applied to the coulotte or top sirloin cap. The Beef Checkoff lists coulotte roast as IMPS 184D and identifies it as the triangular muscle covering the top sirloin. Ordering “sirloin roast” without the top-or-bottom distinction can therefore produce a different cut from the one intended.
Sources: Beef Checkoff — Tri-Tip Roast cut guide (industry source) · Beef Checkoff — Coulotte/Picanha Roast cut guide and 184D identifier (industry source) · USDA Agricultural Marketing Service — Institutional Meat Purchase Specifications
What to specify at the butcher counter
- For tri-tip, ask whether it is IMPS 185C or the defatted 185D specification and whether the package is a whole roast or portion-cut 1185C steaks.
- For picanha, ask for top sirloin cap or coulotte, IMPS 184D, and state the exterior-fat thickness you want retained.
- Ask whether silver skin or heavy surface connective tissue remains under the package.
- Compare usable weight after the requested trim, not only the package price per pound.
- Choose pieces with enough thickness to support the cooking plan; a very thin tail will finish before the center.
- Have the butcher label the exact cut when buying several sirloin items for one event.
Sources: Beef Checkoff — Tri-Tip Steak cut guide and 1185C identifier (industry source) · Beef Checkoff — Coulotte/Picanha Roast cut guide and 184D identifier (industry source) · USDA Agricultural Marketing Service — Institutional Meat Purchase Specifications
The fat specification changes the result
Tri-tip is often sold with relatively modest exterior fat, and USDA distinguishes a standard boneless specification from a defatted one. Picanha is closely associated with its exterior fat layer, but packages marketed as picanha can arrive with different trim levels. Ask for a measured trim rather than assuming every picanha has the same cap.
Remove only the tough membrane or hard excess that interferes with seasoning and browning. When cooking picanha fat-side down over direct heat, watch for flare-ups and move it to the cooler zone as needed. A two-zone setup gives both cuts a place to finish without continuing to darken the surface.
Sources: USDA Agricultural Marketing Service — Institutional Meat Purchase Specifications · Beef Checkoff — Beef picanha grilling method (industry source)
Cook the whole roast by temperature, not a fixed clock
Tri-tip’s broad center and narrow ends do not heat at the same pace. Picanha’s fat layer and thickness also change cooking time. Start with indirect heat or a moderate oven, then use direct heat when a darker exterior is needed. The order can be reversed, but the thermometer—not a minute chart—must decide when the center is ready.
Insert the thermometer into the thickest center without passing through a large fat seam. USDA FSIS requires whole beef steaks and roasts to reach at least 145°F before removal from heat, followed by at least a 3-minute rest. Check more than one location when the roast has a pronounced thick and thin end.
Sources: Beef Checkoff — Tri-Tip Roast cut guide (industry source) · Beef Checkoff — Coulotte/Picanha Roast cut guide and 184D identifier (industry source) · USDA FSIS — Safe internal temperatures for meat and poultry
Picanha can be cooked whole or portioned for skewers
The Beef Checkoff’s picanha recipe portions a whole coulotte into thick strips, bends them onto skewers and uses a hot zone for the exterior plus a cooler zone for finishing. That is one valid format, not a requirement. A whole cap can also be roasted or cooked indirectly and then sliced.
If portioning before cooking, keep pieces similar in thickness and note the grain direction first. Small end pieces should be monitored separately because they can reach temperature earlier than the center portions.
Sources: Beef Checkoff — Coulotte/Picanha Roast cut guide and 184D identifier (industry source) · Beef Checkoff — Beef picanha grilling method (industry source)
Map the grain before seasoning
Tri-tip often has grain running in more than one direction. The Beef Checkoff’s tri-tip guidance recommends identifying the change, separating the roast into its natural sections and slicing each section across its own grain. Marking that direction before cooking is easier than trying to rediscover it under a dark crust.
For picanha, grain direction also matters whether the cap is cooked whole or cut into strips. Rest the meat, rotate each portion so the fibers run across the knife and slice thinly. Cutting with the grain leaves longer fibers in each bite regardless of the cut’s marbling.
Sources: Beef Checkoff — Tri-Tip Roast cut guide (industry source) · Beef Checkoff — Tri-Tip Steak cut guide and 1185C identifier (industry source) · Beef Checkoff — Tri-tip grain and slicing guidance (industry source) · Beef Checkoff — Grilling basics and across-grain slicing (industry source)
Which one should you buy?
- Choose tri-tip for a leaner whole roast that can be carved into many thin slices for sandwiches, platters or a group meal.
- Choose picanha when the top sirloin cap and its specified exterior fat are central to the serving style.
- Choose portion-cut tri-tip steaks when individual servings matter more than presenting a whole roast.
- Choose the more evenly shaped piece when grill space and synchronized service are the main constraints.
- When the label is ambiguous, ask for the sirloin location and IMPS/NAMP number before buying.
Sources & further reading
Sources checked for this guide on November 14, 2026. Recommendations combine the cited information with Marrow’s practical editorial guidance.
- Beef Checkoff — Tri-Tip Roast cut guide (industry source)
- Beef Checkoff — Tri-Tip Steak cut guide and 1185C identifier (industry source)
- Beef Checkoff — Coulotte/Picanha Roast cut guide and 184D identifier (industry source)
- USDA Agricultural Marketing Service — Institutional Meat Purchase Specifications
- Beef Checkoff — Beef picanha grilling method (industry source)
- Beef Checkoff — Tri-tip grain and slicing guidance (industry source)
- Beef Checkoff — Grilling basics and across-grain slicing (industry source)
- USDA FSIS — Safe internal temperatures for meat and poultry